TV Authority Bans Ad for Backing Gay Marriage and Arabic Language

A public service announcement (PSA) from the Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) has been banned from television because of its message in support for gay marriage and the rights of the Arab-Palestinian minority in Israel. The Second Authority for Television and Radio, the public body that supervises Israel’s commercial television and radio stations, banned the PSA, which is entitled “Human Rights: Because without them I’m not Equal.” The Second Authority banned the ad due to this sentence, stating that the law governing commercial television states that the broadcaster will not broadcast any advertising that has a message on a “political, social, public or economic matter” that is a matter of “public dispute.” The Second Authority says the statement made in the ad by Mira Awad, a well-know Arab singer, actress and Hadash supporter (“It’s permitted to speak Arabic without fear”), is also problematic and prevents the ad from being aired.

Steiner in the public service announcement from the Association for Civil Rights in Israel: “Even if I’m a homosexual” – Above: "Censored by the Second Authority for Television and Radio"

Steiner in the public service announcement from the Association for Civil Rights in Israel: “Even if I’m a homosexual” –  Above: “Censored by the Second Authority for Television and Radio”

The minute-long ad includes appearances by such well-known Israeli celebrities as model and actress Galit Gutmann, former Miss Israel Titi Aynow, social activist Daphni Leef,  and others.  In the ad, Aynow, who is of Ethiopian origin, says: “The right to choose and marry whoever I want.” Her words are immediately followed by Adir Steiner, an LGBT activist who participated in the legal battle for the rights of same-sex couples, saying: “Even if I’m gay.” Steiner says his organization was shocked by the ban. He said that while the struggle for human rights sometimes raises controversies, there is still wall-to-wall agreement that human rights are a basic component of Israeli democracy.  “Our clip was intended to raise the awareness of human rights, equality, dignity and freedom, and if an important and central body such as the Second Authority bans it, it seems we still have a great amount of work [remaining],” said Steiner.

Dan Yakir, the chief legal counsel of the ACRI, told Haaretz on Wednesday, December 21, that “in 2016, equality for the LGBT community and the right to speak Arabic are not matters under dispute. The state itself recognizes marriages of same-sex couples who married overseas, and Arabic is an official language in Israel, so the reason for the ban is not at all clear.” Attorney Yakir sent a letter on behalf of the ACRI to the Second Authority’s legal advisor saying that the Authority’s interpretation of the regulations severely harms freedom of expression. The letter states that this case is not just a matter of commercial freedom of expression but also of political speech, which has received especially broad protection in Supreme Court decisions. “If the Second Authority does not change its decision, the ACRI will go to court,” says Yakir.

See the censored public service announcement